| Platinum | Fertitta's Delicatessen |
| Gold | Monjunis Italian Cafe & Grocery |
| Silver | Carrabba's Italian Grill |
| Bronze | Giuseppe's Pastacaffe |
| Top Pick | Frank's Pizza Napoletana |
| Top Pick | L'Italiano Restaurant |
| Top Pick | LA Dolce Vita |
| Top Pick | Notini's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Rotolo's Pizzeria |